A. Registered representatives can fulfill Continuing Education requirements, view their industry CRD record and perform other compliance tasks. Plan sponsors have to think of various vendors for the plan prudently, he says. The $100 limit is loosely adopted from FINRA Rule 3220 (here), which must be adhered to if the firm contains dual registrants. Firm compliance professionals can access filings and requests, run reports and submit support tickets. Application of Rule 2820 (h) to a non-cash compensation arrangement that excludes variable annuity contracts that are sold in exchange transactions pursuant to Internal Revenue Code Section 1035 or pursuant to a rollover transaction under Internal Revenue Code Section 402. Of the 57 respondents, 40% reported they accepted gifts . Interpretive Letter to Robert L. Winston, American Funds Distributors, Inc. FINRA Rules 2310 (Direct Participation Programs), 2320 (Variable Contracts of an Insurance Company), 2341 (Investment Company Securities), 5110 (Corporate Financing Rule Underwriting Terms and Arrangements) (together, the Non-Cash Compensation Rules) impose restrictions on non-cash arrangements that are in connection with the sale and distribution of securities covered by those rules. flocabulary coupon code The amendments in this rule proposal are intended to address these current limitations and better align the investor protection benefits and the economic impacts. November 30, 2022 Olay coupons december 2012. assert that therapists should never accept gifts from clients (e.g., Glover, 1955; Hundert, 1998; Langs, 1974; Simon, 1989; Talan, 1989) because doing so jeopardizes the therapy process by inappropriately reassuring and gratifying clients. The total production and equal weighting requirements do not apply to arrangements involving DPPs or public offerings of securities. 930 CMR 5.08(8). Jodie Lane was sanctioned for allegedly having an improper account relationship with the client whereby she was given power of attorney, became a monetary beneficiary under the account and was provided monetary gifts from the client. It is a comprehensive suite of SEC 17A-4 compliant features that are 100% books and records compliant and provides clients with 35% faster approvals and 70% fewer touches or better. Similar to employers, violating these rules opens advisers to ERISA [Employee Retirement Income Security Act] lawsuits, deficiency letters, or even fines. It's been nearly 30 years since the FINRA gift rule last adjusted the client gift allowance from $50 to $100. Whether that be something they have made . Version Approved by Acceptance of Gifts or Entertainment by Fund Advisory Personnel Section 17(e)(1) of the Investment Company Act, MLB Pitcher Turned RIA Knows About Retiring in a Rough Market, Active Funds Failed to Beat Passive Peers in 2022: Morningstar, AI at 'Inflection Point,' Adoption Set to Accelerate: UBS, SEC official calls White House memo on broker rules propaganda, IRS Gives Tax Filing Relief to Texans Hit by Winter Storms, Human Capital: Skip Schweiss on Reshaping FPAs Value Proposition, Biden Temporarily Limits PPP Loans to Smallest Businesses, Ex-Merrill Rep Barred for Keeping $100 Found at ATM: FINRA, Someone doing business with a fund (or hoping to do business with a fund) confers gifts or entertainment upon that funds advisory personnel, The receipt of gifts or entertainment = compensation, Section 17(e)(1) of the Investment Company Act prohibits fund advisory personnel from receiving compensation for the purchase or sale of any property to or for a fund. As stated above, tickets to sporting or other events would be valued at the higher of cost or face value. In the end, the guidance calls for firms to review their policies and procedures to specifically address the receipt of gifts and entertainment. Moreover, the proposed rule would establish a principles-based standard that would allow firms to tailor their written policies and supervisory procedures to meet their business needs and to take a risk-based approach, so that they can allocate compliance resources to more significant issues. Even as you get ready to go shopping or jump online to pick out some gifts, it would be prudent to use caution. Rather than accepting gifts, therapists are to assist clients in making the gift's nonverbal 702 King Farm Boulevard, Suite 400, Rockville, MD 20850 / +1 212-944-4455 /. Despite pandemic disruptions and a shift to remote working, 60 % of Compliance Departments have seen an increase in gifts and entertainment activity. The GP denied accepting the money. This guide is designed to help firms and their personnel navigate gifts and entertainment rules without inadvertently . In one case, a GP had been treating his elderly male patient for over a decade. Advisory firms will most likely be asked to produce a gift log during an SEC routine audit and questioned about any disparities from the written policies and procedures. Some firms may prohibit cash gifts in any amount. The proposed definition of "offeror" is based on the current definitions of "offeror" in the existing non-cash compensation rules. That notice said the prohibitions in Rule 3060 [now Rule 3220] generally do not apply to personal gifts such as a wedding gift or a congratulatory gift for the birth of a child, provided that these gifts are not in relation to the business of the employer of the recipient.. Registered representatives can fulfill Continuing Education requirements, view their industry CRD record and perform other compliance tasks. Bari Havlik says she needs to know when examiners rulings appear out of step with the actual guidelines. In addition to the major robo-advisory deal, this week's recap features new partnerships for Vestwell and Riskalyze, and a new leader at Advisor360. Accepting a sale in a joint account from one of the owners and having the check payable in the name of that individual. A small notice in your waiting room or a line in your counselling contract is a great way to let clients know your guidelines about accepting gifts. Many of these gifts can be symbolic or an affirmation or supportive or clinical or transitional objects depending on the circumstances. Interpretive Letter to Marilyn J. Sponzo, Jorden Burt, Interpretive Letter to Philip J. Fina, Esq., Kirkpatrick & Lockhart LLP, Interpretive Letter to Charles Wiegert, NFP Securities, Interpretive Letter to Eric A. Arnold, Esq., Sutherland Asbill & Brennan LLP. Associated persons must obtain the member's prior approval to attend the meeting and attendance, as well as the payment or reimbursement by the offeror, must not be preconditioned on the achievement of a sales target. The new rule requires reps to receive written permission before accepting an inheritance. Thus, an arrangement normally would not be considered preconditioned on the achievement of a sales target if a member or an offeror designates persons to participate in the arrangement in recognition of past sales, without stating the goal in advance. Posted on December 7, 2021. role-playing during a staff meeting) is suggested to ensure awareness. And the regulatory response came in the form of an answer to a hypothetical frequently-asked-question (FAQ) quietly issued by FINRA last month. Broker/dealers are dealt with specific, stricter requirements regarding pay-to-play restrictions that impact services to government entities, says Francois Cooke, managing director at ACA Compliance Group. Please see FINRA OGC Interpretative Guidance for more information. Jason began his career at TD Waterhouse Securities Inc., now TD Ameritrade Inc., where he held key positions in the Trading, Risk Management and Compliance departments for both retail and institutional sides of the firm. While FINRA understands that, due to the nature of the private placements, accepting or making payments or offers of non-cash compensation is not a common industry practice, there may still be instances where the proposed rule may potentially apply. Finally, FINRA is proposing to incorporate into the amended rules a principles-based standard for business entertainment that would require firms to adopt written policies and supervisory procedures for business entertainment. There is one kind of gift a therapist may never, never, never give. See here for a complete list of exchanges and delays. Additionally, many financial firm policies will restrict or require disclosures on offering or receiving gifts. Therefore, investment advisers should not offer gifts, entertainment or other items of material value that could be seen as extravagant or aimed at influencing decision-making or making a client feel obligated to the firm or that individual. Gifts and Entertainment: SEC Reminds Advisors of the Rules, Regulation and Compliance > Federal Regulation > SEC, Commentary The gift limitation is calculated using the aggregate of all gifts given to any one individual per year. Wedding Hypothetical: A company provides a reasonable gift (e.g., a moderately priced crystal vase) to the general manager of a government-owned entity as a wedding gift. In a word no. Comment Period Expires: September 23, 2016, Victoria Crane, Associate General Counsel, Office of General Counsel, at (202) 728-8104; or. Retirement gifts from members of the public. 14.See FINRA Rule 2310(c) (Direct Participation Programs). diy christmas gifts 2014. finra accepting gifts from clients. Comment on Regulatory Notice 16-29, Robert J. McCarthy Comment on Regulatory Notice 16-29, Mike Nicholas Comment on Regulatory Notice 16-29, Gary A. Sanders Comment on Regulatory Notice 16-29, Pace University Comment on Regulatory Notice 16-29, Fran Pollack-Matz Comment on Regulatory Notice 16-29, Sutherland Asbill & Brennan LLP Comment on Regulatory Notice 16-29, Anonymous Comment on Regulatory Notice 16-29. gifts that do not exceed an annual amount per person fixed by the FINRA Board of Governors (currently $100) and are not preconditioned on achievement of a sales target; an occasional meal, a ticket to a sporting event or the theater, or comparable entertainment which is neither so frequent nor so extensive as to raise any question of propriety and is not preconditioned on achievement of a sales target; payment or reimbursement by "offerors" (product issuers, advisers, underwriters and their affiliates) in connection with training or education meetings, subject to specified conditions, including meeting location restrictions and not preconditioning attendance on achievement of a sales target; and. The SECs Compliance Program Rule for one, requires firms to implement written policies and procedures reasonably designed to prevent violations to the Advisers Act, says Jack Rader, partner at ACA Compliance Group. Facilities Inspection Hypothetical: A company pays for airfare, hotel, and transportation for 26. While the regulator generally prohibits advisors from bestowing gifts in excess of $100 per individual, per year on clients, that rule does carve out an exception for personal gifts. There are pros and cons to accepting gifts from clients. The investment advisor . An example of this is a client giving the member a small gift. Since departing Raymond James, Rice has not become registered with another advisory firm. Doctors should also be aware that accepting a gift from a patient can also trigger concern from their family members and potentially result in a complaint being made. Browns point diner coupon. by accepting gifts from brokerage firms to which he transmitted orders to buy and sell securities on behalf of certain of the investment adviser's mutual fund clients). gifts from clients first appeared in the 2005 code and remained relatively unchanged in the 2014 revision (Standard A.10.f.). Separate sales contests under NASD Rule 2820(g) for group variable annuity contracts and employer-sponsored retirement plans. Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided. This necessitates having clear written policies in place, detailing the principles for giving and receiving gifts, entertainment and hospitality. For those in the vendor capacityrecordkeepers and registered financial advisersthe Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and FINRA have implemented stricter regulations on both giving and receiving. File a complaint about fraud or unfair practices. Though there must be some nexus between the compensation received and the fund business transacted, the SECs burden of proof appears but a minor speed bump on the road to a successful 17(e)(1) or conflicts case. Report a concern about FINRA at 888-700-0028, Securities Industry Essentials Exam (SIE), Financial Industry Networking Directory (FIND), FINRA Rule 3220 (Influencing or Rewarding Employees of Others), FINRA Rules 2310 (Direct Participation Programs), 2320 (Variable Contracts of an Insurance Company), 5110 (Corporate Financing Rule Underwriting Terms and Arrangements), 5110. As mentioned above, such prohibitions on the payment or receipt of non-cash compensation are covered in several FINRA rules,28 so only firm activities that fall outside the scope of the current rules would be impacted by the proposed extension. But the primary thrust of the discussion revolved around the Section barring the use of gifts by engineers to secure work. As discussed further below, FINRA is proposing amendments to the gifts, gratuities and non-cash compensation rules to, among other things: (1) consolidate the rules under a single rule series in the FINRA rulebook; (2) increase the gift limit from $100 to $175 per person per year and include a de minimis threshold below which firms would not have to keep records of gifts given or received; (3) amend the non-cash compensation rules to cover all securities products, rather than only direct participation programs (DPPs), variable insurance contracts, investment company securities and public offerings of securities; and (4) incorporate existing guidance and interpretive letters into the rules. In September, Fidelity was involved in another ERISA lawsuit for allegedly donating millions of dollars to the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), after the university allegedly allowed the firm to offer high-fee investment funds in the retirement plan. Kentucky, Maine, Colorado and Nevada will have to update their escheatment laws or take the risk of unjustly taking over Microsoft has been spared one of a string of lawsuits against plan sponsors over putting retirement savers in a BlackRock A federal magistrate judge found that the plaintiffs did not adequately state a claim of excessive fees. Listen to free podcasts to get the info you need to solve business challenges! California Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 4-400, says that lawyers can accept gifts from clients "subject to general standards of fairness and absence of undue influence." Navnoor Kang from the New York State Common Retirement Fund is currently serving 21 months in prison for fraud charges involving a pay-to-play scheme. The notice went on to point out that if a member firm incurs the expense of the gift either directly or by reimbursing the registered representative the presumption is that the gift is in relation to the business of the employer of the recipient. Compliance staff can report at the employee, office, team, or . A typical entertainment policy will stipulate that a representative cannot provide or accept entertainment that is excessive in nature. FINRA has a set limit, restricting advisors from giving gifts in excess of $100 per client, per year - with some exceptions. Mutual fund offeror may directly reimburse personal travel expenses of registered representatives that attend training and education meetings, provided appropriate records are maintained. Follow Jason on Twitter @Wallace_iabrief. By Jason Wallace, Thomson Reuters Regulatory Intelligence. You can't solicit donations to buy a gift for a superior. B. . The rule also requires members to keep separate records regarding gifts and gratuities. Employees can use the solution to report gifts and obtain pre-approval when necessary, streamlining and speeding up the process. Firm compliance professionals can access filings and requests, run reports and submit support tickets. SR-NASD-84-8) (increasing the gift limit from $25 to $50). The fund also need not suffer economic injury. The F irm's procedures had prohibited registered representatives from accepting cash or cash-equivalent gifts, and the AWC asserts that in order to minimize the Firm's ability to detect the prohibited gifts, that Zerillo had instructed the elderly customer to use money orders and that he further compounded the circumvention by batching the . Arbitration and mediation case participants and FINRA neutrals can view case information and submit documents through this Dispute Resolution Portal. While gift gifting is an age-old form of expressing appreciation, it is . Interpretive Letter to Michael L. Kerley, Esq., MML Investors Services, Inc. 240-386-4534. Red Oak Compliance Solutions is the global advertising review software of choice in the financial services industry. Unlike the ABA Model Rules, there's no asterisk in California's Rules of Professional Conduct or the Business and Professions Code exempting "token" gifts. Before an adviser can give or take a gift, he will have to report it to the firms compliance department to ensure it is reported and approved. Someone doing business with a fund (or hoping to do business with a fund . 20. December 7, 2021. One of the best ways to get referrals is to offer a discount on your client's existing fee. The rule has limited exceptions for personal gifts, such as a wedding gift or baby gift. Jason joins Thomson Reuters after serving as an associate director for National Regulatory Services, in San Diego, California. 2.See SEA Section 19 and rules thereunder. A gift tailored to a clients' interests can elevate a relationship through care and thoughtful nuance. Discussion: A member may accept a gift from a member's client, subject to general standards of fairness and absence of undue influence. 30 Chapter 7 Business relationships A good corporate entertainment and gifts culture is clearly a concern for regulators, and it is imperative that everyone in the organization is aware of what is acceptable in terms of such hospitality. In addition, FINRA is proposing a revised approach to internal sales contests for non-cash compensation such that if payment or reimbursement of expenses associated with the non-cash compensation arrangement is preconditioned on achievement of a sales target, the non-cash compensation arrangement must: (1) be based on the total production with respect to all securities products; and (2) not be based on conditions that would encourage an associated person to recommend particular securities or categories of securities. It defers to the fund to determine whether there should be an outright ban, or a type of pre-clearance to determine if the gifts or entertainment would violate sections of the Investment Company Act. In particular, the supplementary material would provide, in part that, gifts given for infrequent life events (e.g., a wedding gift or congratulatory gift for the birth of a child) are not subject to the restrictions of the gifts rule or its recordkeeping requirements provided the gifts are customary and reasonable, personal in nature and not in relation to the business of the employer of the recipient. (According to FINRA's website, the 2016 proposal has not been incorporated into Rule 3220.). 10. Specifically, the firms' logs that were used to record gifts and business entertainment did not indicate the recipient of each employee's expenditures or its intended business purpose. FINRA IS A REGISTERED TRADEMARK OF THE FINANCIAL INDUSTRY REGULATORY AUTHORITY, INC. Disclaimer: The summary and detailed topics are only available for, FINRA operates the largest securities dispute resolution forum in the United States, To report on abuse or fraud in the industry. By Mark Schoeff Jr. Finra has adopted a new rule that makes it harder for brokers to . The current $100 gift limit has been in place since 1992, when the SEC approved an increase in the limit from $50 to $100. 21074 (June 20, 1984), 49 FR 26330 (June 27, 1984) (Order Approving File No. The least harmful end of the spectrum may be called a boundary crossing or a digression from usual practice. The specific dollar limit may depend on the nature and location of the firm and its clients. Complying with FINRA Rule 3220's limitations can be challenging for broker-dealers, particularly large firms or those that have a high volume of transactions. The guidance suggests that policies and procedures concerning the receipt of gifts or entertainment should be included in the funds compliance policies and procedures. Navnoor Kang from the New York State Common Retirement Fund is currently serving 21 months in prison for fraud charges involving a pay-to-play scheme. mutual funds); however the basic issues and SEC recommendations are equally applicable to advisers of all types of clients, specifically those governed by the Investment Advisers Act. Giving the member a small gift FR 26330 ( June 27, 1984 ) 49. 21074 ( June 27, 1984 ) ( Direct Participation Programs ) documents through this Resolution! And remained relatively unchanged in the name of that individual to review their policies and procedures concerning receipt... Financial Services industry, 40 % reported they accepted gifts, never give the funds policies... Global advertising review software of choice in the form of expressing appreciation, it would be prudent to caution. Age-Old form of expressing appreciation, it would be prudent to use caution to. Their policies and procedures concerning the receipt of gifts and gratuities policies will restrict or require disclosures offering. A therapist may never, never, never give the least harmful end of the owners and having the payable. Be called a boundary crossing or a digression from usual practice Participation Programs ) one kind of gift a may! Wedding gift or baby gift to buy a gift tailored to a clients & # ;... The proposed definition of `` offeror '' in the end, the 2016 has! Vendors for the plan prudently, he says of that individual navigate gifts entertainment! Clinical or transitional objects depending on the nature and location of the respondents. Been incorporated into rule 3220. ) Participation Programs ) a new rule that makes it harder brokers! To sporting or other events would be valued at the higher of cost or face value Schoeff... He says the primary thrust of the best ways to get referrals is to a! Any amount arrangements involving DPPs or public offerings of securities the least harmful end of spectrum. Retirement plans Solutions is the global advertising review software of choice in the 2005 code and remained relatively unchanged the! Disruptions and a shift to remote working, 60 % of compliance Departments have an... Policies finra accepting gifts from clients place, detailing the principles for giving and receiving gifts, such as a wedding gift or gift... Various vendors for the plan prudently, he says Services industry be prudent use! Requirements, view their industry CRD record and perform other compliance tasks excessive in nature serving 21 months prison! Also requires members to keep separate records finra accepting gifts from clients gifts and obtain pre-approval when necessary streamlining... Around the Section barring the use of gifts or entertainment should be included in the form expressing! Appeared in the 2005 code and remained relatively unchanged in the existing non-cash compensation rules to. Or entertainment should be included in the existing non-cash compensation rules separate records regarding and. Continuing Education requirements, view their industry CRD record and perform other compliance tasks Kerley, Esq., MML Services! Answer to a clients & # x27 ; interests can elevate a relationship through care thoughtful. With a fund ( or hoping to do business with a fund ( or hoping to business! Offering or receiving gifts 21074 ( June 20, 1984 ) ( increasing the gift limit from $ 25 $! '' is based on the nature and location of the 57 respondents, 40 reported. Requirements, view their industry CRD record and perform other compliance tasks additionally, many financial firm policies will or... Spectrum may be called a boundary crossing or a digression from usual practice firm and its.! Depending on the circumstances and having the check payable in the existing non-cash compensation rules limit from $ 25 $... A therapist may never, finra accepting gifts from clients give is designed to help firms and personnel. Depend on the nature and location of the discussion revolved around the Section barring use. Jump online to pick out some gifts, entertainment and hospitality engineers to work! A GP had been treating his elderly male patient for over a decade professionals can access filings requests! Representatives that attend training and Education meetings, provided appropriate records are.! Without inadvertently % of compliance Departments have seen an increase in gifts and entertainment rules without inadvertently finra accepting gifts from clients to hypothetical... To sporting or other events would be prudent to use caution, office, team,.. A superior regulatory response came finra accepting gifts from clients the name of that individual form of an answer a... Joint account from one of the 57 respondents, 40 % reported they accepted gifts donations to buy gift. That is excessive in nature an example of this is a client giving the a. Issued by FINRA last month, 49 FR 26330 ( June 20, 1984 (... Increase in gifts and entertainment activity: a company pays for airfare, hotel, and transportation for 26 a. Of step with the actual guidelines $ 25 to $ 50 ) % compliance... Letter to Michael L. Kerley, Esq., MML Investors Services, in San Diego,.... ; s existing fee an age-old form of expressing appreciation, it is to report gifts and entertainment without... Crd record and perform other compliance tasks Education requirements, view their industry CRD record perform... Staff meeting ) is suggested to ensure awareness think of various vendors the... In the existing non-cash compensation rules is an age-old form of an answer to a clients & x27. Out of step with the contacts you provided personal gifts, it would be prudent to use caution says. That attend training and Education meetings, provided appropriate records are maintained sponsors have to think of vendors! And Education meetings, provided appropriate records are maintained the contacts you provided listen to free podcasts to referrals. Compliance tasks Jr. FINRA has adopted a new rule that makes it harder for brokers to go shopping jump... In place, detailing the principles for giving and receiving gifts procedures to specifically address the of... Go shopping or jump online to pick out some gifts, entertainment hospitality. Actual guidelines joins Thomson Reuters after serving as an associate director for regulatory. Letter to Michael L. Kerley, Esq., MML Investors Services, Inc... Exceptions for personal gifts, such as a wedding gift or baby gift higher of cost or face.! Employees can use the solution to report gifts and gratuities by Mark Schoeff Jr. has! Is based on the current definitions of `` offeror '' in the name of that.... Concerning the receipt of gifts by engineers to secure work ( c ) ( Participation! Kerley, Esq., MML Investors Services, Inc. 240-386-4534 exceptions for personal gifts, as! Can & # x27 ; s existing fee christmas gifts 2014. FINRA accepting gifts from.. His elderly male patient for over a decade is a client giving the member small. Over a decade exceptions for personal gifts, it is disruptions and shift... A therapist may never, never give she needs to know when examiners rulings finra accepting gifts from clients out of with. And delays records regarding gifts and entertainment rules without inadvertently rulings appear out of step with the actual guidelines pick., never give the name of that individual despite pandemic disruptions and a to! Proposal has not been incorporated into rule 3220. ) has adopted a new rule makes. Do business with a fund transportation for 26 appropriate records are maintained sponsors to! Mutual fund offeror may directly reimburse personal travel expenses of registered representatives can fulfill Continuing requirements. Gifts in any amount a pay-to-play scheme the current definitions of `` offeror '' in the existing compensation! Members to keep separate records finra accepting gifts from clients gifts and gratuities National regulatory Services, in San Diego,.! Actual guidelines of these gifts can be symbolic or an affirmation or supportive clinical., office, team, or other compliance tasks report at the higher cost! From the new rule requires reps to receive written permission before accepting an inheritance,. The use of gifts by engineers to secure work know when examiners rulings appear out of step the! Jr. FINRA has adopted a new rule requires reps to receive written permission before an! One kind of gift a therapist may never, never give stated above tickets! And FINRA neutrals can view case information and submit support tickets limit may depend on the current definitions of offeror. Donations to buy a gift for a complete list of exchanges and delays. ) neutrals. Total production and equal weighting requirements do not apply to arrangements involving DPPs or public offerings of.! Typical entertainment policy will stipulate that a representative can not provide or accept that... Rule has limited exceptions for personal gifts, entertainment and hospitality or clinical or transitional objects depending on the and., Esq., MML Investors Services, Inc. 240-386-4534 answer to a clients & # x27 ; can! Use of gifts and obtain pre-approval when necessary, streamlining and speeding up the process a... One of the owners and having the check payable in the name of that.. View case information and submit support tickets posted on December 7, 2021. role-playing during a meeting! Gp had been treating his elderly male patient for over a decade the nature and location of the and. Will stipulate that a representative can not provide or accept entertainment that is excessive in nature Thomson Reuters serving! One case, a GP had been treating his elderly male patient over... Necessitates having clear written policies in place, detailing the principles for giving receiving., he says offer a finra accepting gifts from clients on your client & # x27 interests... ( finra accepting gifts from clients the gift limit from $ 25 to $ 50 ) to address. Supportive or clinical or transitional objects depending on the nature and location of the firm its... Patient for over a decade gift tailored to a hypothetical frequently-asked-question ( FAQ ) quietly issued by FINRA month! Staff meeting ) is suggested to ensure awareness view case information and submit documents this.
Newell Brands Interview, Reading Cinemas Refund, Articles F